And No, I Don’t Need Your Certificate of Feminism
Every October, two types of people become active: first, women who celebrate Karwa Chauth with joy; and second, a handful of privileged influencers and celebrities who try to shame them for doing so.
This year, it’s Twinkle Khanna saying, “These days, by 40, you could be on your way to your second marriage, so what’s the point of fasting? You don’t need men to last that long anymore.”
Before that, it was Ms. De calling Karwa Chauth regressive—a ritual for insecure women with nothing better to do. She even called it “Karwa Ch*t.” A woman of her age, an author we all grew up reading, saying such a thing was a shock to me. Both women are well read and well educated, and they have large followings.
Let me tell you my story.
I
started fasting on my own. My husband told me very clearly on day one, “Please
do what you want to do. Mom might ask you, but it’s your choice whether you
follow any rituals or not.” This wasn’t just about Karwa Chauth; it applied to
all the festivals and rituals followed at my in laws’ home. I will always
respect him for putting me ahead of himself.
I was not forced. I was not brainwashed. I was asked to choose what I wanted to do. I am grateful for that and I value it. My mother in law took care of everything, as she understood the difficulties of being a career woman and a new mom. In fact, my in laws played a huge part in raising my two boys. They literally helped raise me, too. I learned what it meant to run a home and a family from my mother in law. This happens with almost all women, but many choose not to acknowledge it in the name of individuality or freedom - call it whatever you like.
I
am an educated woman and a feminist. They say education opens people’s minds. I
guess I worked on that part - jokes apart, I have two undergraduate degrees,
two postgraduate degrees, and a PhD. I founded Indian Women in Hospitality. I
have spent my entire life advocating for DEI and for women’s right to work,
lead, earn and speak. I have been working for almost three decades.
And I KEEP Karwa Chauth. By choice. So please, don’t tell me it’s regressive.
The
problem with these so called influencers; and what irritates me - is their
sheer disconnect from ground reality. They live hugely privileged lives, with a
battery of servants at home and PR teams to write their thoughts. Some are
school dropouts who have never had to struggle for a day in their lives.
And then they sit in their penthouses and preach to women around them and to women in small towns - about what empowerment means.
By the way, who reads their thoughts? Maybe thousands or even lakhs of people on social media. Do you think the women in our villages and small towns follow them? They don’t.
I have seen women in
villages on Karwa Chauth. Do you know what that day means to
them? It is the ONE day they get to care for themselves.
They get to dress up like brides again. They get to wear new bangles, apply mehendi, and wear new sarees or beautiful lehengas. They get to enjoy themselves with other women - to laugh, sing, gossip and bond. For a few hours, they are not someone’s daughter in law, mother or wife who is cooking and cleaning. They are just themselves: beautiful, happy women celebrating together. Praying together.
You want to take that away from them and mock them; and call it feminism? What is the harm? What is the harm if a woman wants to pray for her husband’s long life? Everything we do is based on a belief system. Even God is a belief.
To Ms. Khanna and Ms. De:
Let’s Be Honest
Saying that by 40 you could be on your second marriage, so there’s no point in fasting, trivializes marriage itself. Commitment is not a joke. The fact that second marriages exist doesn’t mean first vows are worthless. If anything, it proves how much we value companionship. Even if you are divorced, would you wish something bad for the other person?
And calling women who fast insecure is easy when you have never lived the life of an ordinary Indian woman. Insecurity is not fasting. Insecurity is needing to mock other women to stay relevant. I am married to a seafarer; he is hardly ever home when I fast, but it’s one beautiful bond I share with my husband. I know he is often far away, across time zones and we can’t even speak. But that’s the beauty of love, trust and care.
My feminism does not ask me to hate men. My feminism does not ask me to mock other women. My feminism allows me to be strong at work and soft at home, to lead a boardroom and also fast for the man I love. Both can coexist.We don’t need men to pay our bills. We want our husbands to live healthy lives. We can survive on our own. We have built our own careers and livelihoods.
I fast because I pray for him and for us. Because I love him. Because we built a family together. Because love is not a transaction based on need; it is a choice of the heart.
Just three days after Karwa Chauth is Ahoi Ashtami, when women fast for their children not just their sons (as it was followed earlier), but their daughters too. This is a beautiful adaptation.
It’s not a hard and fast rule; it’s a choice women make. If they can’t fast for health reasons, they perform ‘udyapan’. Many have water after reciting the katha. Women don’t observe the fast when they are pregnant or lactating. They also choose to adapt the ritual to suit their needs and what they can do comfortably. It’s not forced.
Karwa Chauth is also not necessarily like what Karan Johar made it look like in his movies. We sometimes dramatize our rituals too much. It falls on Chaturthi, and many people fast for Ganeshji. Some fast only until noon; there are different variations.
I have two sons, and when they get married, my daughters in law will have the same freedom to choose what they want to do.
Let people have a choice.
Don’t want to observe Karwa Chauth? Don’t. We will respect your choice. But don’t you dare shame our sisters and friends in villages or working women in offices, who observe it with pride.
Feminism is about CHOICE. DEI is about CHOICE. And my choice is to celebrate. So for Karwa Chauth, like many other women, I will wear my red bangles, apply my mehendi, and wait for the moon. Not because I am regressive, but because I am free.
And
no Instagram post by a celebrity will take that freedom away from me.
First posted on www.theiwh.com



This Navratri, I miss her immensely. Tomorrow will mark one year since she left for her heavenly abode. I feel the great void she has left and I miss her every day. At the same time, I am deeply grateful for the time we shared and feel blessed to have had her as my mother-in-law. She meant so much to me.




